by selwin » Tue Aug 24, 2010 4:46 pm
"I don't think it would even be compared to the matches Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker had. I don't even know if Goldberg still has it in him to step in the ring and compete let alone face The Undertaker in the Superbowl of wrestling. I was expecting a lot from Brock Lesnar vs Goldberg at Wrestlemania 20 and I was sadly disappointed, that match wasn't close to where it was hyped to be, especially with Stone Cold as the referee. If Goldberg can't do it then, he definitely can't do it now."
First of all, if you're going to compare it to Michaels/Taker, you're preparing yourself for a let down because the two bouts would be completely different, and in order to appreciate either you'd have to accept the fact that Goldberg is not Shawn Michaels. Few wrestlers are. As a matter of fact, I can only think of one.
Secondly, I'm really sick of Goldberg detractors using WM20 as a crutch. It wasn't a good match, I agree, but the reasons for it being bad had NOTHING to do with wrestling and EVERYTHING to do with ego. To put it bluntly, Goldberg and Lesnar had a bad match because they wanted to stick it to every single crowd in that arena booing them for leaving.
"Mind you, whenever The Undertaker faced someone with zero talent in wrestling, not to mention 6 years of not wrestling, The Undertaker tend to experience the worst. His match with Giant Gonzales is widely considered as his worst match ever. His match with King Kong Bundy flopped in every way possible. His match with Big Boss Man remains his only Wrestlemania match to receive 'boring' chants from the fans and is largely reckoned as the worst Hell In A Cell match in existence. A-Train destroyed every quality he and Big Show could have provided with his undeniable slow paced work. And the last but definitely the least, we saw how his match with Mark Henry became not only the worst casket match ever held, but also one of the worst matches in the history of Wrestlemania."
Comparing Goldberg to Gonzalez or Bundy is an insult. Both men were too immoble to do anything due to size or weight constraints, and the same can be said about Big Show at the time and Mark Henry at any given point in his career. Goldberg's lean, has speed incomparable to anyone on that list, and the stamina to keep it up. I'll agree that Bossman and A-Train were much better wrestlers that had bad outings with the Dead Man, but there was a time in Taker's career when an Undertaker match was bad because of the Undertaker, and I'd argue that Bossman's bouts against him was on the cusp of that time. A-Train and Big Show may have no excuse, but I'm giving Bossman a by.
"IMO, The Undertaker can't (and won't) carry Goldberg to a legendary match if they do have a match next year.
And yes, I'm saying Diesel, Sid, and Batista have more wrestling talent than Goldberg. Any match featuring Goldberg cannot last longer than five minutes after all. If it does, it will be like Goldberg vs Lesnar. "
I'll agree with you to a point on some of those comparisons. Depending on what time in Nash's career we're talking about, I'll agree that he has been better than Goldberg, and considering what time in his career we're talking about Batista, I'll once again conceed that he is better than Goldberg. Sid Vicions....well, 2 out of 3 ain't bad. The point is, Diesel and Batista, two guys I'd at least put on level if not slightly above Goldberg have had great bouts with the Deadman, some of which happened in the twilight of Batista's career when he just didn't have it in him most nights unless he was fighting Taker. Considering Taker's main prerrogative in any match is to make money and make the other guy and himself look good in the process, I doubt he'd let Goldberg drop the ball even if he wanted to.
Goldberg's capable of classic bouts if he's worked with properly, and Taker's the right kind of opponent for him. There would be more sizzle than steak, sure, but it doesn't mean they couldn't put on a really good, hyped up, crowd playing big man battle of titans. I say this to every Goldberg retractor, watch his bout with Hogan on Thunder, his first bout against Hogan, it was PPV worthy.
I'm not saying Goldberg's perfect, I'm not even saying he's a good wrestler, I'm just saying under the right circumstances he can put out a good bout.